Rift deepens between Turkish gov’t, top court with Erdoğan’s heavy criticism

A deepening conflict between the Justice and Development Party (AK Party) government and the Constitutional Court took on a new dimension on Saturday, when the prime minister directed harsh criticism at the court’s judges over some of their recent rulings while the court’s top judge responded to the prime minister, saying they are doing their job.

The conflict suggests the top court is the next target of the AK Party government, points out Today’s Zaman in an analysis:

Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, while delivering a speech in İstanbul on Saturday, slammed the Constitutional Court for its decision to overturn a ban on Twitter as well as for its ruling to partially annul a law to restructure the Supreme Board of Judges and Prosecutors (HSYK).

“Everyone should know the limits of their authority. If they [the Constitutional Court judges] want to conduct politics, they should first take off their robes,” Erdoğan stated.

On April 2 the Constitutional Court ordered that access to Twitter be restored, calling the two-week ban on the social media platform a violation of the right to free expression. Twitter was blocked after the prime minister expressed his dislike of the microblogging site after several users posted audio recordings related to an investigation into government corruption that became public with police raids and detentions carried out on Dec. 17, 2013.

Erdoğan harshly criticized the court after the ruling, saying he did not respect the decision.

On April 11 the Constitutional Court partially annulled parts of the HSYK law that gives the justice minister sweeping powers over the board. The court’s decision was published in the Official Gazette on April 12.

On Saturday, the prime minister said: “The Constitutional Court defends the rights of an international company instead of defending the rights of its own nation. It is a disrespect to the nation to make a ruling [on Twitter] while hundreds of files [complaints] are waiting at the court. The court also made a ruling about the HSYK.” The prime minister also asked the Constitutional Court to “know its boundaries.”

In response, Constitutional Court President Haşim Kılıç said the judges of the court are “doing their jobs.” “We are fulfilling our duties within the authority vested in us by the Constitution,” Kılıç told a Turkish daily on Saturday. According to Kılıç, people will understand the court’s rulings once the court releases its reasoned decisions.


The top judge also responded to claims that the Constitutional Court had reviewed a complaint about the HSYK law even though the complaint was not on the court’s agenda. Kılıç said the claim did not reflect the truth. “The topics to be discussed by the court are picked one week beforehand, and the court’s members are informed about the court’s agenda. The members work on those topics and then attend the court’s sessions. The HSYK law was among the topics the court was supposed to discuss. The Constitutional Court members knew that the law would be discussed by the court,” he stated.

Kılıç was also asked if he is planning to run as a candidate for president in the approaching elections. In response, the judge said he is not considering running. “I am working very hard. All talks and analyses on this [presidency] issue are evaluations without my knowledge,” he stated.

With its ruling to partially annul the HSYK law, the Constitutional Court has secured the support of prominent legal experts.

Constitutional law expert Professor Zafer Üskül, a former deputy of the AK Party, said the top court should issue its reasoned decision on the HSYK law soon. According to the professor, the court has made the right decision by annulling parts of the law that gives the justice minister broad powers over the HSYK but pointed out that the minister has already reshaped the board by removing many members and appointing others. Üskül said the Constitutional Court’s annulment of the HSYK law will not impact the moves already taken by the justice minister on the board.

Shortly after the HSYK law went into effect in late February, Justice Minister Bekir Bozdağ removed many members from the HSYK and appointed new members in their place.

Üskül said the HSYK members who have been removed can appeal to administrative courts to be reappointed to their former posts at the board. However, he added, even if the courts decide to reinstate these members to their former positions, those posts are already occupied by new members who must resign before the former members can return to their posts.

Former Justice Minister Professor Hikmet Sami Türk also applauded the Constitutional Court for its decision on the HSYK law. Türk said the law was aimed at subordinating the board to the justice minister, a move that violated the rule of law. “Subordinating the HSYK to the justice minister and rendering the board’s 21 members ineffective would go against the independence of the judiciary,” he stated.

The former minister also noted that the Constitutional Court had also annulled an article of the HSYK law which said all inspectors and administrative staff working for the HSYK would be removed from their jobs. According to Türk, the article required a mass removal of staff at the HSYK. “This is an article that could only be seen during coup periods,” he noted.


About yavuzbaydar

Yavuz Baydar has been an award-winning Turkish journalist, whose professional activity spans nearly four decades. In December 2013, Baydar co-founded the independent media platform, P24, Punto24, to monitor the media sector of Turkey, as well as organizing surveys, and training workshops. Baydar wrote opinion columns, in Turkish, liberal daily Ozgur Dusunce and news site Haberdar, and in English, daily Today's Zaman, on domestic and foreign policy issues related to Turkey, and media matters, until all had to cease publications due to growing political oppression. Currently, he writes regular chronicles for Die Süddeutsche Zeitung, and opinion columns for the Arab Weekly, as well as analysis for Index on Censorship. Baydar blogs with the Huffington Post, sharing his his analysis and views on Turkish politics, the Middle East, Balkans, Europe, U.S-Turkish relations, human rights, free speech, press freedom, history, etc. His opinion articles appeared at the New York Times, the Guardian, El Pais, Svenska Dagbladet, and Al Jazeera English online. Turkey’s first news ombudsman, beginning at Milliyet daily in 1999, Baydar worked in the same role as reader representative until 2014. His work included reader complaints with content, and commentary on media ethics. Working in a tough professional climate had its costs: he was twice forced to leave his job, after his self-critical columns on journalistic flaws and fabricated news stories. Baydar worked as producer and news presenter in Swedish Radio &TV Corp. (SR) Stockholm, Sweden between 1979-1991; as correspondent for Scandinavia and Baltics for Turkish daily Cumhuriyet between 1980-1992, and the BBC World Service, in early 1990's. Returning to Turkey in 1994, he worked as reporter and ediytor for various outlets in print, as well as hosting debate porogrammes in public and private TV channels. Baydar studied informatics, cybernetics and, later, had his journalism ediucatiob in the University of Stockholm. Baydar served as president of the U.S. based International Organizaton of News Ombudsmen (ONO) in 2003. He was a Knight-Wallace Fellow at University of Michigan in 2004. Baydar was given the Special Award of the European Press Prize (EPP), for 'excellence in journalism', along with the Guardian and Der Spiegel in 2014. He won the Umbria Journalism Award in March 2014 and Caravella/Mare Nostrum Prize in 2015; both in Italy. Baydar completed an extensive research on self-censorship, corruption in media, and growing threats over journalism in Turkey as a Shorenstein Fellow at the Kennedy School of Government at Harvard.
This entry was posted in Turkey. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s