Their cities razed to the ground, mayors removed, Kurds lose faith in Turkey

‘I feel like Diyarbakır does: dreary, angry, resentful. But still standing…’

This comes from a ‘local rapporteur’ from the southeastern corner of Turkey; devastated, battered – both morally and physically.

I will explain.

These are the days even a heavyweight European political leader like Frank-Walter Steinmeier would be seen as ‘privileged’ (!) to meet his Turkish counterparts.

Such are the conditions that even his recent visit only helps explain the growing gaps in the dialogue between Ankara and the EU. Nothing, as it seems, works anymore. No matter how hard you try for a return to common sense.

But Kati Piri is not as ‘privileged’ as Steinmeier.

Piri, Turkey Rapporteur of the European Parliament, is now blacklisted, a persona non grata, no longer allowed to meet the government.

Her misdemeanour? According to Bekir Bozdağ, Turkish Justice Minister, ‘she prepares her reports as terror organisations want her to do.’

This is the reason a visit by the European Parliament delegation to Ankara on Wednesday had to be postponed. Martin Schulz, President of the European Parliament let us know that de-selecting a delegation member is not acceptable.

What would Piri do?

Probably as she has always done.

Not only meeting Turkish ministers, but also representatives of the elected parties, the opposition, lawyers, critical journalists and the NGO’s. She would go on with fact-finding about breaches of freedoms, imprisonments, violations of property rights etc. That’s her job, her mission.

Since almost all the oppositional activity these days seem ‘criminalized’ in the eyes of the Turkish government, it’s better she is cut off from doing so.

But this won’t stop Turkey’s brave ‘local rapporteurs’ to shed light on the reality on the ground. Nurcan Baysal is one of them. Living in Diyarbakır, refusing to leave the city no matter how hard the conditions become, she sends her articles almost daily, reporting about the daily life, and how Kurds feel.

Even in these days, when Turkey in Freedom House’s global internet freedom index is downgraded from ‘partly free’ to ‘not free’ – now placed along Iran, Belarus, Sudan and Saudi Arabia – she persists in an act of courage, as reporting from mainly Kurdish provinces is like a walk in the minefield.

‘My friends from the west (of the country) are asking me how I feel’ she wrote in her latest blog, posted by news site T24. ‘

‘I feel like Diyarbakır does: dreary, angry, resentful. But still standing…’

Then, she walks us through the streets of Diyarbakır, visiting public places, talking to common people. All she conveys is despair, gloom.

She visits her favourite coffeehouse. The owner tells her that people stopped coming, since Selahattin Demirtaş, the popular leader of the pro-Kurdish HDP was arrested along with ten MP’s. ‘Nothing is the same anymore, everybody is in sorrow,’ he tells her.

People suffer in this city,’ she reports. ‘It’s not an easy living; not easy to survive, to feel hope, to continue…’

‘People here gave so much of themselves for peace that, what they were subjected to after all these efforts caused enormous disappointment.’

‘Our media is no longer. NGO’s are no longer. No more municipalities of our own. No longer elected deputies. That our elected representatives are treated this way leaves us with a resentment impossible to repair.’

I remembered when reading Baysal’s article, my last visit to the ancient district of Sur, in Diyarbakır. Last spring, I was in a small group of journalists, together with Nurcan, visiting parts of the neighborhood, under siege by the security forces. We had been stopped at a certain point. Gloom was like a dense fog covering the ground, Kurdish mothers and grandmothers sitting together, chainsmoking, waiting for the news whether those stuck out there would come out alive.

Not much of Sur is left today.


8 months after the lifting of the curfew, a Kurdish family is at the rubble of their house that once was.

But, perhaps, it stands weak in comparison to what happened with the neighboring city of Şırnak. Three days ago the eight-month long curfew was lifted and all we could see was a city entirely razed.

‘Homecoming has started, but there is no home to return to’ was the poignant, spot-on headline of daily Cumhuriyet, showing pictures of some women sitting on a desert-like ground. Official figures talk about at least 2.000 buildings demolished. According to estimates by human rights organisations, between 70-90.000 people had left the town due to clashes and operations – amounting to 80-90 % of the total population.


The city of Şırnak was razed to the ground after eight months of security operations.

Seizures sweep through the region.

On Wednesday, trustees were appointed to HDP strongholds like Mardin, Van and Siirt.

Tuncer Bakırhan, the mayor of Siirt, was arrested days ago.

So was Bekir Kaya, mayor of Van.

In Mardin, the governor was given the role as mayor, replacing Ahmet Türk.

If anything, the ousting of Türk bears the most powerful significance of events.

74 years old, this gentle politician, who once was entrusted by the late President Turgut Özal as an intermediary, given a role as a bridge for Kurdish peace, sees in the winter of his life yet another blow to his efforts for ending the ethnic vendetta in Turkey.

One can only imagine the depth of the scar inflicted on the Kurdish psyche as he is stripped off his duties as elected by an overwhelming vote.


Ahmet Türk, ousted mayor of Mardin, was subjected to severe torture during the military rule, following the coup in September 1980. ‘I prayed to die those days’ he said in an interview.

The mainly Kurdish/Alevi province of Tunceli/Dersim feels the heat too. Some days ago, co-mayors of the city, Mehmet Ali Bul and Nurhayat Altun, were also arrested together with 10 other local politicians and NGO representatives. Deputy governor has taken over their position.

Meanwhile, another HDP deputy is now on the firing line.

It is Sibel Yiğitalp, a young female deputy of Diyarbakır, who is now charged, we learn, between 11 and 28 years of imprisonment. She is accused of statements like ‘it is the state security forces that demolished the historic sites in the old district of Diyarbakır’, or ‘taking part unarmed in illegal demonstations and defying to leave them despite warnings’ and, ‘belonging to a terrorist organisation.’


Scorched earth policies, seizures of local administrations, charging and arresting elected politicians, blocking the international rapporteurs, exercising a policy based on denial and defiance…

But the reality is out there, impossible to cover up.

It will haunt the AKP government, no matter what.

This is what every journalist loyal to the profession, knows for a fact.

‘If a candidate at the presidential elections in 2014 is under arrest today, how can I as a foreign investor feel ever safe and secure, people ask me these days’ said Cenk Sidar, a young economy strategist based in Washington DC, said in a recent interview, commenting on the growing economic crisis signals that come from Turkey.

The candidate he mentioned was Selahattin Demirtaş, now sitting in solitary confinement.



About yavuzbaydar

Yavuz Baydar 39 yıllık gazeteci. Mesleğe İsveç Radyosu'nda muhabir olarak başladı, oradan TV ve yazılı basına geçti. Sırasıyla Cumhuriyet İsveç muhabirliği, BBC Türkçe Servisi'nde yapımcı-sunuculuk, Yeni Yüzyıl'da dış haberler servis şefliği, Milliyet'te editörlük yaptı. 1999 yılı başında Milliyet Okur Temsilcisi olarak, medyada kurumsal bir 'özdenetim' yapısı olan ombudsmanlığı Türkiye'ye tanıtan ve ilk uygulayan kişi oldu. Bu görevi Milliyet ardından Sabah'ta da sürdürdü. Toplam 15 yıl süren bu görevi nedeniyle dünyanın en kıdemli ve 'uzman' ombudsmanlarından biri sayılıyor. Baydar, merkezi ABD'de bulunan Dünya Medya Ombudsmanları Örgütü'nde (ONO) başkanlık ve yürütme kurulu üyeliğini de üstlendi. Türkiye'ye döndüğü 1990'lı yılların ortasından bu yana çeşitli TV kanallarında başta Soru-Cevap olmak üzere çok sayıda analiz-tartışma programını hazırlayıp sunmuş olan Baydar, düzenli olarak Süddeutsche Zeitung ve The Arab Weekly için yorumlar yazmakta. Baydar, Ocak 2014'te bir grup meslektaşı ile beraber medya bağımsızlığı ve özgürlüğü alanında çalışmalar yürütmek üzere Bağımsız Gazetecilik Platformu'nun (P24) kurucu üyeleri arasında yer aldı. 2000 yılında 'Okur Temsilcisi' olarak yaptığı çalışmalar nedeniyle Çağdaş Gazeteciler Derneği'nin (ÇGD) Özel Ödülü'ne layık bulunan Baydar, 2014 yılında da, Avrupa'nın 'Pulitzer'i sayılan Avrupa Basın Ödülü'nü (EPP) 'meslekte mükemmeliyet' tanımlamasıyla aldı. 2004'te Michigan Üniversitesi'nde Knight-Wallace Araştırma Bursu ile 'Ortadoğu, demokrasi ve medya' konulu mesleki çalışmalar yapan Baydar, 2014 sonbaharında da Harvard Üniversitesi'ne bağlı Kennedy School'da 'Shorenstein Fellow' olarak Türkiye medyasında sansürün ve mali yozlaşmanın yayılmasını ele alan uzun bir rapor yayınladı. Baydar ayrıca Guardian, El Pais, New York Times gibi gazetelere de aralıklı olarak yorum ve analiz makaleleri yazıyor.
Bu yazı AKP, Demirtaş, EU, HDP, Kurds, PKK, Turkey içinde yayınlandı. Kalıcı bağlantıyı yer imlerinize ekleyin.

Bir Cevap Yazın

Aşağıya bilgilerinizi girin veya oturum açmak için bir simgeye tıklayın: Logosu hesabınızı kullanarak yorum yapıyorsunuz. Log Out / Değiştir )

Twitter resmi

Twitter hesabınızı kullanarak yorum yapıyorsunuz. Log Out / Değiştir )

Facebook fotoğrafı

Facebook hesabınızı kullanarak yorum yapıyorsunuz. Log Out / Değiştir )

Google+ fotoğrafı

Google+ hesabınızı kullanarak yorum yapıyorsunuz. Log Out / Değiştir )

Connecting to %s